there are some guides here that are totally good stuff and some not so much , never heard of , or seen a rating menu on them , but it varies pretty widely , I am sure some have better days than others and a sense of humor to go with it ....
cant stand a old crusty zero fun no sense of humor guide myself . been out with a few barnacle bill types in the past , that old and crusty thing might get you on some fish , but it ain't much fun sometimes to be on the boat with that guy .....just saying